Novice Masters of St. Paul of the Cross Province
- Anthony Calandri: 1854-1863
- Liberatus Bonelli: 1863-1866
- Gaudentius Rossi: 1866-1869
- John Dominic Tarlattini: 1869-1872
- John Thomas Stephanini: 1872-1875
- Amadeus Garibaldi: 1875-1878
Became member of Spanish province where he died in 1924 - Contantine Colclough: 1878-1884
- Aloysius Blakely 1884-1887
- Frederick Lang: 1887-1893
- George Basel 1893-1899
- Denis Callagee: 1899-1902
- Fidelis Kent Stone: 1902-1905
- Stanislaus Grennan: 1905-1908
- Clement Lee: 1908-1911; 1923-1929
- Alexander Croker: 1929-1935
- Cassian Sullivan: 1935-1938
- Berchmans Lanagan: 1938-1947
- Paul Francis Nager: 1947-1952
Elected General Consultor in 1952. Ronald Murray served remainder of term. - Ronald Murray: 1953
- Gregory Flynn: 1953-1962
- Augustine Paul Hennessy: 1962-1965
- Timothy Fitzgerald: 1965-1968
- Novitiate closed between 1968 and 1970 in lieu of the establishment of a new college program which moved the novitiate ahead two years until after college graduation.
- Aquinas McGurk: 1970-1977
Appointed for the year 1970; Elected in 1971; Appointed in 1974; Resigned 1977 - Raphael Amrhein: 1977-1981
Appointed 1977; Reappointed 1978; Resigned 1981 - Inter-Province Novitiate Established: 1981
Novitiate Locations
- 1854-1926: Pittsburgh
- 1926-1938: West Springfield
- 1938-1941: Pittsburgh
- 1941-1943: West Springfield
- 1943-1948: Pittsburgh
- 1948-1949: Union City
- 1949-1968: Pittsburgh
- 1970-1981: West Hartford
- 1981-1986: Pittsburgh
- 1987-1997: Shrewsbury